THE 34-9 REPORT

The Month in Review.

New Decisions. Emerging Issues. Informed Practice.

Each monthly edition of The 34-9 Report brings together newly released Georgia workers’ compensation decisions, an issue index, substantive case summaries, and links to the original decisions and their research dossiers.

INSIDE THE 34-9 REPORT
The 34-9 Report
▼
IN THIS ISSUE
Arising Out Of / Course of Employment 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5
Assessed Attorney Fees 2 · 3 · 5 · 14
Catastrophic Injury / Lifetime Benefits 6
Causation 1 · 2 · 7
Change in Condition 8
Medical Treatment / Authorization 9
Notice 5
Penalties / Interest / Late Payment 5 · 10 · 11
Surgery / Invasive Treatment 12 · 13 · 14
Temporary Partial Disability 4
Temporary Total Disability 4 · 6 · 8
SBWC - ALJ Awards
1.  Claim Denied Due to Insufficient Evidence of Work-Related Injury
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Causation
Summary: The ALJ held an evidentiary hearing on May 6, 2026, regarding the Employee's claim for workers' compensation benefits following an alleged work-related injury on April 5, 2024. The Employee contended that he sustained a back injury while performing his duties at the Charging Station, where he was required to lift heavy batteries and bend to insert screws. However, the Employer's supervisor testified that the Employee did not report any injury and that ergonomic measures were in place to prevent such injuries. The ALJ found the Employee's testimony inconsistent and uncorroborated, particularly regarding the condition of the equipment and the timeline of injury reporting. Consequently, the claim for benefits was denied based on a lack of credible evidence linking the injury to the Employee's work activities.
Case No. 2024-051539 | ALJ: Johnny Mason (Atlanta): 06-23-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
2.  Compensability of Neck Injury and Attorney's Fees Awarded
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Causation · Assessed Attorney Fees
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on April 30, 2026, regarding Employee's claim for her neck injury to be recognized as part of her compensable work injury, which already included her left shoulder. Employee contended that her neck injury arose from a work-related incident on September 16, 2023, while lifting a garbage can, while Employer argued that the neck condition was pre-existing and unrelated. The ALJ found Employee's testimony credible and determined that the evidence supported that the neck injury was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition caused by the work accident. The ALJ ordered Employer to reimburse Employee for certain out-of-pocket medical expenses and awarded attorney's fees for the unreasonable defense of the claim.
Case No. 2023-109541 | ALJ: Sharon H. Reeves (Macon): 06-11-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
3.  Employee's Claim for TTD and Medical Treatment Denied Due to Lack of Credible Evidence
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Assessed Attorney Fees
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on April 15, 2026, to determine the employee's entitlement to workers' compensation benefits following an accident on March 6, 2024, where she claimed injuries to her right knee and back. The employee sought 25 weeks of TTD benefits, additional medical treatment, and penalties for late payments and unreasonable defense. The employer/insurer contended that the claim was medical only, asserting the employee had fully recovered and was not entitled to benefits. After evaluating the evidence and witness credibility, the ALJ found that the employee did not sustain a disabling injury related to her work accident, as she had a history of knee and back issues prior to the incident and failed to demonstrate ongoing disability or need for additional treatment. Consequently, the ALJ denied the employee's requests for benefits and attorney's fees for both parties.
Case No. 2024-022718 | ALJ: Viola S. Drew (Atlanta): 06-11-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
4.  Employee's Compensable Injury and Entitlement to Benefits
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Temporary Partial Disability · Temporary Total Disability
Summary: The ALJ ruled on the Employee's entitlement to benefits under the Georgia Workers’ Compensation Act following a compensable injury to her thoracic spine on February 7, 2025. After undergoing kyphoplasty, the Employee sought TTD benefits from September 12, 2025, through January 26, 2026, and TPD benefits for missed work due to medical appointments. The Employer/Insurer contested the claim, arguing that the Employee's low back symptoms were unrelated to her work injury. The ALJ found that the Employee had aggravated a preexisting condition due to her work-related injury and awarded TTD and TPD benefits, along with medical expenses, while denying the request for attorney’s fees.
Case No. 2026-011949 | ALJ: W. Brian Mallow (Albany): 06-30-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
5.  Employee Granted Benefits for Work-Related Injury Despite Employer's Non-Appearance
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Notice · Penalties / Interest / Late Payment · Assessed Attorney Fees
Summary: On June 11, 2026, the ALJ held an evidentiary hearing regarding Employee 1's claim for benefits following a work-related injury on April 3, 2025. The Employer did not appear officially, leading to a determination that the hearing could proceed based on proper notice being given. The ALJ found that the Employee sustained injuries to his neck and left shoulder while performing his job duties and that he provided timely notice of the injury to the Employer. The Employer's failure to respond to requests for admissions resulted in those facts being deemed admitted. Consequently, the ALJ awarded the Employee TTD benefits, medical expenses, and assessed attorney's fees against the Employer for various violations, including failure to maintain workers' compensation insurance and for unreasonable defense tactics.
Case No. 2025-043899 | ALJ: Jerome J. Stenger (Savannah): 06-24-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
6.  Denial of Catastrophic Designation and Reimbursement of TTD Benefits
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Catastrophic Injury / Lifetime Benefits · Temporary Total Disability
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on May 4, 2026, regarding Employee's request for a catastrophic designation under OCGA 34-9-200.1(g)(6) following her injury on March 13, 2017, when she was stabbed while working as a forensic technician. The Employer sought reimbursement for overpaid TTD benefits from March 27, 2024, to November 10, 2024. The ALJ found that Employee did not meet the burden of proof for a catastrophic designation, as she was able to perform work as a tax preparer and beautician, earning an average income that indicated her capability to work in substantial numbers within the national economy. Consequently, the ALJ denied both Employee's request for catastrophic designation and Employer's request for reimbursement of TTD benefits.
Case No. 2017-010555 | ALJ: Sharon H. Reeves (Macon): 06-29-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
7.  Employee's Request for Migraine Treatment Denied Due to Lack of Causal Connection to Work Accident
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Causation
Summary: The ALJ denied the Employee's request for treatment of migraines, concluding that the migraines were not causally related to her work accident on 1/22/2021. The Employee claimed she suffered a head injury during a fall at work, but the Employer/Insurer argued that her migraines were unrelated to the accident and stemmed from a subsequent incident in 2023. The ALJ found inconsistencies in the Employee's testimony and medical history, noting that she initially denied a head injury and that medical records did not support her claims of migraines being linked to the work accident. The ALJ determined that the Employee failed to meet her burden of proof regarding the causal relationship between her migraines and the work-related fall.
Case No. 2021-012513 | ALJ: Melodie Belcher (Macon): 06-08-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
8.  Employer's Unilateral Suspension of TTD Benefits Denied Due to Lack of Change in Condition
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Change in Condition · Temporary Total Disability
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on April 14, 2026, regarding Employee's claim for TTD benefits from December 7, 2025, to January 24, 2026, which Employer contested based on a release to regular duty work by Employee's ATP. The ALJ found that Employer had properly suspended benefits but determined that Employee did not experience a change in condition for the better that would justify the suspension. The ALJ noted that Employee's symptoms and functional limitations remained consistent, and the surveillance evidence did not convincingly demonstrate an ability to return to work without restrictions. Consequently, the ALJ awarded TTD benefits for the disputed period.
Case No. 2024-009876 | ALJ: Sharon H. Reeves (Macon): 06-03-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
9.  Compensability of Left Hip Injury and Authorization of Treatment
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Medical Treatment / Authorization
Summary: The ALJ ruled on June 23, 2026, regarding Employee's claims for disability benefits stemming from a February 6, 2025, accident. Employee sustained a compensable injury after slipping and falling, leading to treatment for a right knee injury and a pre-existing left hip condition. Although the Employer/Insurer accepted the left hip as a compensable injury, they contested the authorization of treatment by Dr. Flandry. The ALJ found that while Dr. Flandry's treatment was not authorized, it was necessary due to the compensable injury, designating him as the authorized treating physician for the hip. The issue of permanent partial disability benefits was reserved for future determination.
Case No. 2025-009428, 2025-012760 | ALJ: William Cain (Columbus): 06-23-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
10.  Employee's Request for Late Payment Penalty Denied Due to Timely Mailing of Settlement
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Penalties / Interest / Late Payment
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on May 4, 2026, regarding a claim settled by no-liability stipulation, where the Employee contended that the Employer failed to timely pay the settlement and sought a 20% late payment penalty, attorney fees, and litigation expenses. The Employer argued that the settlement was timely paid. The ALJ found that the Employer mailed the settlement checks on June 12, 2025, within the required 20 days following the board's approval on May 28, 2025. Despite the checks being reported as stolen, the ALJ concluded that the act of mailing constituted timely payment under OCGA § 34-9-221(b). Consequently, the ALJ denied the Employee's requests for penalties and fees.
Case No. 2021-113154, 2022-044464 | ALJ: Richard H. Sapp III (Dalton): 06-29-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
11.  Late Payment Penalty Award for Settlement Proceeds
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Penalties / Interest / Late Payment
Summary: The ALJ awarded a late payment penalty to the Employee after determining that the Employer and Insurer failed to timely pay the Employee's portion of a settlement due to an error in the mailing address. The settlement, approved on February 4, 2026, required payment within 20 days, but the checks were mailed to an incorrect address on February 6, 2026, and were not received. Replacement checks were issued on February 25, 2026, which was beyond the deadline. The ALJ found that the Employer and Insurer did not demonstrate that conditions beyond their control excused the late payment, thus granting the Employee a 20% penalty on the settlement amount.
Case No. 2025-061624 | ALJ: Sharon H. Reeves (Macon): 06-05-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
12.  Authorization of Right Shoulder Surgery Based on Work-Related Injury
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Surgery / Invasive Treatment
Summary: The ALJ ruled in favor of the Employee, authorizing right shoulder surgery after determining that the surgery was reasonably required and causally related to a work injury sustained on October 9, 2024. The Employee, a service technician, fell while working and subsequently experienced significant shoulder pain. Despite conflicting medical opinions regarding the causation of the rotator cuff tear, the ALJ found credible evidence that the Employee's pre-existing shoulder condition was aggravated by the work accident. The Employer/Insurer contested the surgery's relation to the work injury, but the ALJ concluded that conservative treatments had failed and the recommended surgery was necessary for the Employee's recovery.
Case No. 2024-104921 | ALJ: Nicole D. Tifverman (Savannah): 06-09-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
13.  Denial of Requested Surgeries for Work-Related Injuries
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Surgery / Invasive Treatment
Summary: The ALJ denied the Employee's requests for lumbar surgery and hip replacement surgery following a compensable work-related accident on August 18, 2022, which resulted in multiple serious injuries. The Employee sought these surgeries based on recommendations from treating physicians, but the Employer/Insurer contested their necessity. After reviewing extensive medical evidence, including multiple IME reports, the ALJ concluded that neither surgery was reasonably required, as they were unlikely to provide relief or restore the Employee to suitable employment. The Employee remains entitled to continued medical treatment for his work injuries for the remainder of the 400 weeks of medical care.
Case No. 2022-086752 | ALJ: William Cain (Columbus): 06-05-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
14.  Employee Entitled to Spinal Cord Stimulator Payment
DECISION DOSSIER
Issues: Surgery / Invasive Treatment · Assessed Attorney Fees
Summary: The ALJ held a hearing on April 21, 2026, to determine the Employee's entitlement to workers' compensation benefits for a spinal cord stimulator following a September 5, 2024, work-related accident. The Employer/Insurer contested the necessity of the stimulator, asserting it was unrelated to the compensable injury. The ALJ found the Employee credible and accepted the opinion of the authorized treating physician (ATP), Dr. Grimm, who recommended the stimulator as medically appropriate. The ALJ granted the Employee's request for reimbursement of out-of-pocket expenses and health insurer payments but denied the request for assessed attorney's fees, concluding the Employer's defense was reasonable.
Case No. 2024-097571 | ALJ: Meg Hartin (Atlanta): 06-02-2026 | SBWC release: 07-22-2026
© 2026 The 440 Authority, LLC. All rights reserved.
STAY CURRENT WITH THE DECISIONS THAT MATTER

New decisions can reveal how Georgia's ALJs are interpreting statutory provisions, applying appellate precedent, and resolving recurring disputes. The 34-9 Report keeps practitioners informed of these developments as they emerge, without the burden of reviewing every newly released decision.