GA Comp Authority
Advance Sheets
October 28, 2026
Georgia Appellate Decisions
Issues: Burden of Proof · Credibility · Medical Treatment / Authorization · Standard of Review · Temporary Total Disability
In this dispute over entitlement to TTD and ongoing medical benefits after the employer and insurer controverted Stanley Smith’s claim, the Court of Appeals held the superior court erred by applying de novo review and reversed, affirming the State Board’s denial of TTD and further medical expenses. The ALJ found the claim compensable, denied TTD under Maloney, and sought a medical exam; the Board adopted parts of the ALJ award but vacated the exam order and concluded record evidence—post-February 2024 gaps, stopping pain medication, inconsistent testimony, and a passive job search—supported denying resumed benefits. Judgment reversed.
SBWC Appellate Division
Issues: Appellate Division Review · Average Weekly Wage / Compensation Rate
The dispute concerned the correct weekly workers' compensation rate after an ALJ awarded benefits at two-thirds of a stipulated average weekly wage ($1,090.79→$727.19). The Appellate Division had affirmed the ALJ’s March 27, 2026 award, but on a joint motion for reconsideration it concluded two‑thirds exceeded the statutory maximum applicable to the November 14, 2022 injury under O.C.G.A. § 34-9-261. Citing its authority to amend awards, the Appellate Division amended only the weekly rate to $725.00, leaving all other findings and benefits intact.
SBWC ALJ Awards
Issues: Causation · Medical Evidence and Causation · Medical Treatment / Authorization · Surgery / Invasive Treatment
This ALJ trial decision resolved an Employee’s request for authorization and payment of a left knee replacement after a 10/04/2012 workplace fall; the Employer/Insurer contested causation and reserved a statute-of-limitations defense for future income claims. The ALJ found, based on persistent post‑accident treatment and narrative opinions from Drs. Barnes and Pope, that the 2012 traumatic event was a contributing causal factor to current degeneration despite multifactorial causes (including seizures and ongoing work). The ALJ granted the request and directed the Employer to authorize and pay for the left knee replacement.
Issues: Authorized Treating Physician · Catastrophic Injury / Lifetime Benefits · Claimant Attorney Fees / Fee Approval · Credits / Offsets / Overpayment · Temporary Total Disability · Therapy / Rehabilitation Treatment
An ALJ designated the Employee's work injury catastrophic under OCGA §34-9-200.1(g)(6), finding treating physicians Dr. Pearce and Dr. Musick more credible than Employer IMEs (Dr. Grimm; Atlanta Psychiatric). Relying on Dr. Musick’s restrictions and vocational expert Mike McCord’s opinion that no prior or other work exists in substantial numbers under those restrictions, the ALJ ordered appointment of a rehabilitation supplier, designated Dr. Musick as authorized provider, restarted TTD from October 22, 2025 (credit for PPD paid after that date), and awarded 25% of TTD to the Employee's attorney (up to 400 weeks).
Issues: Accident / Injury · Arising Out Of / Course of Employment · Causation · Claimant Attorney Fees / Fee Approval · Assessed Attorney Fees
This Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) award resolved whether the Employee proved a compensable July 12, 2021 work injury and related benefits. The ALJ denied all claimed benefits (TTD, TPD, ongoing medical treatment with Dr. Kasow) and denied assessed attorney’s fees, finding the record showed chronic low back complaints predating July 12, 2021, inconsistencies between the Employee’s testimony and contemporaneous medical and employer records, delayed accident reporting, and insufficient proof that job duties aggravated a preexisting condition. The ALJ therefore dismissed the claim and declined to reach the asserted March 22, 2022 superadded injury or AWW dispute.
Issues: Costs and Expenses · Medical Bills / Expenses · Medical Treatment / Authorization · Assessed Attorney Fees
The ALJ determined whether the self‑insured employer must reimburse the claimant for an out‑of‑area functional capacity evaluation (FCE) and related travel, whether assessed attorney's fees are warranted, and whether the employer may compel a subsequent local FCE. Finding the Yeager FCE reasonable and necessary based on the authorized treating physician's referral and disagreement with the prior Maguire FCE, the ALJ ordered reimbursement of $1,005 plus mileage and lodging, denied assessed attorney's fees, granted the employer leave to require a subsequent Augusta‑area FCE if sought, and reserved permanent‑impairment/PPD issues.
Issues: Causation · Change in Condition · Change of Physician / Panel Issues · Claimant Attorney Fees / Fee Approval · Costs and Expenses · Penalties / Interest / Late Payment · Assessed Attorney Fees
ALJ decision of the State Board of Workers' Compensation resolving whether the employer validly suspended temporary total disability benefits. The ALJ found the employer failed to prove a change in condition for the better, weighed competing medical opinions, concluded the employee developed compensable CRPS from the January 15, 2024 injury and remained unable to perform her job, ordered reinstatement of TTD from December 14, 2025 with credit for prior PPD, granted a change of authorized physician to Dr. Marcus Fulcher, and denied the 15% late-payment penalty and assessed attorney's fees.
Issues: Medical Treatment / Authorization · Penalties / Interest / Late Payment · Assessed Attorney Fees
At an ALJ hearing, Employee sought assessed attorney’s fees and civil penalties for Employer’s refusals to authorize four ATP‑recommended evaluations and for failing to file WC‑3s. The ALJ found Employer reasonably contested the 3T brain MRI with DTI, the speech‑language cognitive evaluation, and ENT/audiology testing based on conflicting evidence and IME opinions, but unreasonably defended an OT home evaluation given treating‑physician records; awarded $1,000 assessed fees for that defense, assessed a $400 OCGA §34‑9‑18(a) penalty for admitted failure to file WC‑3s, and denied other fee and late‑payment penalties. Employer must pay counsel $1,000 and the Board $400 within 20 days.
Issues: Causation · Assessed Attorney Fees
In this ALJ decision the Employee’s claim for workers’ compensation benefits for a right‑hand crush injury was denied. The ALJ applied O.C.G.A. §34‑9‑17’s rebuttable presumption after a urine test within eight hours detected 2,040 ng/ml carboxy‑delta‑9‑THC, and, relying principally on Dr. McCurdy’s forensic opinion, found the Employee failed to rebut that marijuana use caused the injury. The defense was found reasonable; no monetary benefits and no assessed attorney’s fees were awarded, and no penalties were imposed.